It’s been quite a while since our group walked out of the screening of Alien vs. Predator, wide-eyed and stunned at the terrible acting and idiotic story. Being the eternal optimist, I held out hope until the last half hour of the film, but to no avail. Why was I not surprised, or any of us for that matter? And why, you may ask, did I end up buying the DVD when it came out? I can only answer that with four words:
“Know what to expect.”
We all went into the movie knowing full well that it was a popcorn flick. I, personally, went for no other reason than to see the two creatures pitted against each other in battle. The lack luster acting and reaching plot didn’t affect me in the least, because I bought my ticket with full expectations of seeing crap. That does not mean, however, that I did not enjoy it (as evidence of my DVD collection). The fight scenes were fantastic, and I was able to eat my candy to two franchise greats that ranked at the top of my ‘favorites’ list. Yes, I knew what to expect, and anything more than that was a bonus. As with any cult favorite (and we all have them, those dark film skeletons in the back of our closets), you’re most likely not going to receive the silver screen’s pedigree. But I digress….
At the beginning of March, Frank Miller’s “300″ will be released to audiences, and I must say I went through the gambit of emotions while watching the trailer. It tells the story of the Battle of Thermopylae, where 300 Spartan soldiers held off waves of the massive Persian army at a small hot spring. It was, historically, one of the finest examples of valor and courage, blind or not. That being said, if you’ve seen the trailer for the movie, you will notice many, MANY historical inaccuracies, ranging from charging rhinos and elephants behind the Persian lines, to a tattooed, body-pierced menacing Xerxes, the Persian King.
Having great interest in this era, I couldn’t help but feel betrayed as Hollywood was bastardizing another moment in history that doesn’t need any “spicing up” to begin with (don’t even get me started on Pearl Harbor). Can’t we just tell a story, people?! Is the fact that 300 soldiers held off millions not enough of a pillar to stand on for a plot? In a few years, we’ll see a movie about how the World Trade Center was brought down by a dragon army, with Justin Timberlake leading troops in to tame the fallen beasts and turn them against each other. And the sad part is, we will go and watch it – and it will probably do well.
Now for the flip side of the coin, the Devil’s Advocate’s review. In keeping with the “know what to expect” motto, I can sit content with the realization that this movie is not meant to be historically accurate, nor is it meant to portray events as they happened (at least to a fine point). It is based on a graphic novel by an artist known for his fantastic renditions and very characteristic mood. Having seen Sin City and loved it, I am withholding any
judgments against this movie from an artistic viewpoint. In fact, I can’t wait to see it and would easily say that I haven’t been this excited for a film in quite a while.
I’ll be in line to see this when it comes out, no doubt, but I am praying that they at least do the content (as skewed as it may be from actual events) justice. I am more than ready to suspend disbelief for this, so I’ll stick to the history books for the nitty gritty, and watch “300″ to see those events through the eye of an artist.
Check out these links to learn more about the real Battle of Thermopylae:
Wikipedia – The Battle of Thermopylae – The facts.
Gates of Fire by Stephen Pressfield – Historical fiction that follows a young scribe, and lone survivor of the battle.
The Hoplite – Battle analysis and geographic information.
Recent Comments